Ratings sourced from Google Business Profile · Last refreshed July 2026

Nicole Phelps Agency LLC American Family Insurance

Insurance Agents · O'Fallon, MO

5.0(15 reviews)RNM Score 68/100

5.0★ rating from 15 Google reviews reflects strong local customer satisfaction.

Listing data last updated May 11, 2026 · sourced from public Google Business Profile data

🗺️ Get Directions 📍2390 State Hwy K, O'Fallon, MO 63368, USA

🕐Hours: Not listed — call to confirm availability

✏️ Write a Review Is this your business? Claim it free →

Ratings & Reviews

+ Write a Review

15 customer ratings on Google

Write a review here to help future customers choose the best local pros.

✏️ Write a Review See Google reviews →

How Nicole Phelps Agency LLC American Family Insurance compares in O'Fallon

At 5.0★ from 15 ratings, Nicole Phelps Agency LLC American Family Insurance rates above the 4.7★ average of the 6 nearest insurance agents we track in O'Fallon, scoring higher than 4 of them.

Other Insurance Agents in O'Fallon

Early Edge Insurance: Allstate Insurance

5.0 (121)

2917 State Hwy K Ste H, O'Fallon, MO 63368, USA

Dillehay Insurance Agency

5.0 (70)

7322 Village Center Dr, O'Fallon, MO 63368, USA

UltraCar Insurance LLC.

4.9 (69)

801 S Woodlawn Ave #26, O'Fallon, MO 63366, USA

Alternatives Insurance Agency

4.7 (37)

206 W Terra Ln, O'Fallon, MO 63366, USA

AAA O'Fallon Insurance and Member Services

3.7 (46)

2277 State Hwy K, O'Fallon, MO 63368, USA

Insurance Brokers Group

4.9 (214)

1001 Rondale Ct, O'Fallon, MO 63368, USA

← All Insurance Agents in O'Fallon ← Browse all Insurance Agents ← Missouri directory List your business free Report incorrect information